Spring loaded emergency starter. Must have...

The friendliest place on the web for anyone who enjoys boating.
If you have answers, please help by responding to the unanswered posts.
See posts with no answers
S

Searios

Senior Member
Joined
Nov 11, 2012
Messages
247
Location
Hong Kong
Excellent info! Thanks for posting this. Great item to have in the trick bag!
 
When I worked for the Forest Service in 1967 we had a diesel generator out behind the big house. We started the Diesel engine by hand .... a crank. We'd engage the compression release and begin the cranking.

The engine was one cylinder. It was horizontal and looked much like a bottle shaped cannon. It probably had a 3" bore and a 5" stroke. The engine was about 30" long and rested on a rectangular cement base.

Back to cranking. I was about 25 years old and frequently needed several attempts the get the thing going fast enough to start. The time it took to stop cranking and reach over to trip the compression release was critical. If you cranked fast enough and managed to engage the compression quick enough ... the old thing started.

Then we had power in the house.



I don't see any reason a wind up starter couldn't be applied to the fwd end of the crankshaft. Some lawn mowers have wind up starters. The starter I envision would have a stout spring and a very low geared crank that may take considerable time to "wind up" the spring. Would be easy to make one commercially and I'm sure all the components could be found off the shelf.
 
Last edited:
I got the video to play... simple, neat!
 
Art said:
In WWII types of plane engines were started via 12 ga shot gun shell. I think some PT Boat engines were also.
Click to expand...

True. I never used a 12 ga. to start one, but I used a 12 ga. on one that didn't start one time.
 
healhustler said:
True. I never used a 12 ga. to start one, but I used a 12 ga. on one that didn't start one time.
Click to expand...

12 ga. "slug" will instantly stop nearly any regular sized engine. Goes through the block. Past experience...!!
 
Wow, that's pretty cool.

For those that can't run that video, just search on YouTube and you can find some videos of that spring starter.
 
The nicest crank start setup I have seen was on a Brit Enfield diesel, used to mix cement.

The truck was until there was enough oil pressure the valves could not close.

This was done more to protect the unit from union "workers" that could not be bothered to check the oil.

Low oil, no operation so the morter would be hand mixed , seemd to work well.

Crank fast enough by hand ,the valves would operate and chug chug chug!
 
Lucas made spring starters and they've been around for years and I've used them to start cranes/excavators/pumps and site trucks.
I posted on here some time ago of the benefits of having one in the spares locker.
Great to see the idea taken up.


I just can't believe you guys never took out the slug from the shell ! !
I've used them on the Lysander radial aircraft engines and Field Marshall tractors and they worked perfect.
 
Last edited:
modern diesels often require power to open fuel solenoid or run common rail injectors. The days of mechanical diesels seem over.
 
SCOTTEDAVIS said:
Not through but will crack a bit of cast iron, there is an exotic 12 gauge round that does a bit better then the 1oz lead slug, see video 2.
Click to expand...

Scott - In 1971, hitting a 1960 383 cid Chevy engine. 12 ga. slug - went through side of the block, stopped it cold.

Slug you show on video would suffice too, I'm sure.

When the heavily armored and superior weaponry bank robbers were fighting cops in LA several years ago I wondered why the cops did not simply begin hitting their armor protected heads with 12 ga. slugs?? Even if the armor had been tough enough to thwart penetration the slug would have knocked them off their feet and the impact-shock would probably have knocked them out! At minimum the slug would have greatly disoriented their coordination and reasoning functions. Talk about getting a concussion! - LOL
 
Most of the solenoids actually shut the fuel off.
There are literally millions of mechanical boat engines out there still working and while the benefits of a common rail are well known I wouldn't have one in a boat for love nor money. I've seen too many twin and single engine boats (mostly, but not all Volvo powered) towed back into harbour for me to place any trust in them until they become bullet proof.
 
Art said:
Scott - In 1971, hitting a 1960 383 cid Chevy engine. 12 ga. slug - went through side of the block, stopped it cold.

Slug you show on video would suffice too, I'm sure.

When the heavily armored and superior weaponry bank robbers were fighting cops in LA several years ago I wondered why the cops did not simply begin hitting their armor protected heads with 12 ga. slugs?? Even if the armor had been tough enough to thwart penetration the slug would have knocked them off their feet and the impact-shock would probably have knocked them out! At minimum the slug would have greatly disoriented their coordination and reasoning functions. Talk about getting a concussion! - LOL
Click to expand...


I think only Jack Bauer can make those head shots in a running gun fight in the streets.:D
 
BaltimoreLurker said:
I think only Jack Bauer can make those head shots in a running gun fight in the streets.:D
Click to expand...

Those crap-head-robbers were calmly walking and firing their superior weapons much of the time. Armaments they wore made it too heavy for them to move very quickly. It would have been easy to hit their heads with 12 ga. slug. Three police officers, each firing 12 ga slugs... the jerks would have much sooner been stopped; IMHO. That crazy gun fight went on for too much of a long, long time!
 
bayview said:
modern diesels often require power to open fuel solenoid or run common rail injectors. The days of mechanical diesels seem over.
Click to expand...
True, but it requires very little electricity to operate the fuel system. You could very easily be in a situation where your batteries are strong enough to run the engine, but not strong enough to start the engine. That's where something like this could be a life-saver.

The problem I see is that this thing needs to be mounted on the engine in place of the traditional starter. So, in an emergency you have to break out the tool kit, remove the normal starter, and mount this in its place. That ain't gonna happen any too fast! Either that or you leave this permanently mounted and ALWAYS have to start the engine manually.

It would be nice to have something along these lines that could be mounted IN ADDITION to a normal, electric starter, rather than instead of one. Then if the batteries are too run down to start the engine, you could just start it up with this, but in other cases use the electric starter.
 
Many long distance cruisers have multiple battery banks and one or two ways to charge batteries...and possibly have a small inexpensive booster battery charger aboard to boot.

While the spring starter is tempting as a good idea...I think I am more likely struck by lightning and killed than not have the possibility of starting my engine eventually due to low battery power.

Now if I am going to carry a spare starter due to my cruising style and distance from help....I will seriously contemplate it then...
 
psneeld said:
Many long distance cruisers have multiple battery banks and one or two ways to charge batteries...and possibly have a small inexpensive booster battery charger aboard to boot.

While the spring starter is tempting as a good idea...I think I am more likely struck by lightning and killed than not have the possibility of starting my engine eventually due to low battery power.

Now if I am going to carry a spare starter due to my cruising style and distance from help....I will seriously contemplate it then...
Click to expand...

I would sooner carry a spare regular starter. At least that way once I change it I don't have to change it back. And with multiple battery banks the likelihood of not enough cranking power is fairly low as ps stated.
Then again I usually anchor on a hill just in case:lol:
 
jleonard said:
I would sooner carry a spare regular starter. At least that way once I change it I don't have to change it back. And with multiple battery banks the likelihood of not enough cranking power is fairly low as ps stated.
Then again I usually anchor on a hill just in case:lol:
Click to expand...

:rofl::rofl::rofl:
 
jleonard said:
I would sooner carry a spare regular starter. At least that way once I change it I don't have to change it back. And with multiple battery banks the likelihood of not enough cranking power is fairly low as ps stated.
Then again I usually anchor on a hill just in case:lol:
Click to expand...
That's old school you old far*. ;)

heck back then when I lived on my 30 Cape Dory Ketch, with its gigundo 12 hp, one lung Yanmar with compression release...you could sail along with the compressor release activated...throw it and the freewheeling prop would start her right up.

now that I all growedup..my dingy is almost 12hp....:D
 
Geez, single engine owners sure get desperate. However, a box of shotgun shells is cheaper than a spare starter. :thumb:
 
It seems to me that changing out a starter would not be a pleasant task.

If I need to start my engine and the started is inop. then I will replace the starter once not add a springy thing then need to replace it again.

I have several ways to get power to the starter if the starter battery's are down.
 
What if the starter is dead.....slugs and other electricity sources will not help much then.
 
Searios said:
What if the starter is dead.....slugs and other electricity sources will not help much then.
Click to expand...


If you worry about that then carry a spare starter, simple.

I would rather the job once instead of installing the spring and then having to change it again to replace the started. I don't think I would leave the spring on ILO a real starter.
 
I was thinking that I'd get one of these and just get rid of all the wiring hassles to the starter. Simplify - house power only.

But then I thought - what if I stall the engine while docking? So ... never mind.
 
These things cost about the same or more then a regular starter so no thanks. Starting at 1500-5000 I don't get the benefit.

http://au.alibaba.com/products/spring-starter-diesel.html


The electric version really has me scratching my head.

Spring Starter Electric version, View Spring starter, Kineteco Product Details from Kineteco International Ltd on Alibaba.com

Spring_Starter_Electric_version.jpg
 
Last edited:
Neat device. But it is only going to give maybe a turn or two of the crank, so that motor better be primed!!
 
$125 to $175 gets me a new starter for my JD 4045. Seems pretty much a simple choice to carry the replacement part if your going to carry a spare. Will have a spare raw water pump. See no reason to try to adapt an electric pump for when the mechanical one eventually fails.

Ted
 
"Then again I usually anchor on a hill just in case:)"

I am with Art!!!:rofl::rofl::rofl::flowers::flowers:

Al
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Similar threads

rgano
Will it start?
Replies
25
Views
2K
rgano
rgano
Seabiscuit4
Robert beebe passage maker 56 for sale
Replies
2
Views
3K
Seabiscuit4
Seabiscuit4
C
  • Locked
2003 Pacific Trawler 40 in turnkey condition, lying Bainbridge Island WA -- $224,000
Replies
9
Views
4K
CompuNerd
C
M
  • Locked
For Sale 34 Marine Trader Trawler must go - $14,999
Replies
7
Views
3K
mdek
M
B
Fuel discharge experience
Replies
29
Views
3K
psneeld
psneeld

Latest posts

Back
Top Bottom