The statement it makes is that it probably doesn't get used for anymore than a jaunt down the river before being tied to a berth and having a team clean her up
Actual liveaboard usage and cruising reality will change things.
I recognize that two people can look at the same thing and see something differently.
I am also aware that there exists some level of skepticism around the marine ratings agencies. However, they are as close to an independent and qualified examiner of seakeeping ability we have available for this discussion and difference of opinion on the capabilities of this particular boat.
Since this boat was manufactured and sold in Europe in 2013, it has a requirement that it be rated by the National Marine Manufacturers Association under the supervision of the International Marine Certification Institute. While I am sure that many don't give a hoot, when I am shopping, I do pay pretty close attention to this rating system unless there are specific stability tests available which there are mostly not.
This vessel was rated CE A and the specification for that rating is pasted here.
Definitions: A. OCEAN: Designed for extended voyages where conditions may exceed wind force 8 (Beaufort scale) scale) and significant wave heights of 4 m and above, and vessels largely selfsufficient. B
Now, perhaps Simi has more insight into whether or not this boat would float on a mill pond, but others claiming expertise in the subject see it as quite sea worthy.
I would feel quite safe on this boat about anywhere I expect.
As to the comment on lacking light and airy cabins....I am not sure what further attribute beyond wall to wall windows and opening doors in the pilot house and salon it would take to qualify for this designation so I will leave it at that.
The other thing I have often noticed when looking at boats is that when the hull and exterior of a boat are as well conceived and clean lined as this boat is, the mechanical systems are often well found with fine engineering, design, and workmanship as well That is what I see in this boat. Gardner main with dry stack and keel cooling, Northern Lights genny, and robust electrical system. I can never see myself undertaking a build, but if I did, it would look a lot like this.
Bill