Battery Help Please

[Knotyourwife]

I did not know I had to add water to my batteries, boat wont turn over and seller recommends. I got down there and popped of one lid and I don't see any water-should I . How much do I add? Does any one have a decent video?
Thank you in advance!

 

[AKDoug]

Water should be over the top of the plates, distilled water. My guess would be it's going to be too late to get a full recovery on those batteries... just an opinion, good luck!

 

[DavidM]

This link gives a step by step procedure for checking water in batteries with pics: https://www.wikihow.com/Check-Car-Battery-Water-Levels

If you can't see any water then it is below the plates and the battery is probably shot. You might try adding water and charging, but the battery will not likely return to full charge.

David

 

[Alaskan Sea-Duction]

Sounds like you need new batteries.

Welcome to TF

 

[Lepke]

If you boat has an older charger, it might be over charging and causing the "water" to evaporate too quickly. My current boat came with an old constant volt charger and was going thru water like crazy. When I changed the batteries I went to a Sterling charger and now use less than half the water.

 

[fletch]

I did the same thing

They were shot, forgot all about it last winter, I changed out to AGM's, if you change types, be sure and check your charger, they require different settings. Depending on the age of the charger, might not be compatible.

 

[Knotyourwife]

Only one of the four batteries appeared to be low on water, that was a two hour project, but I topped them all off. One of the boaters here just checked with a voltage meter and 3 were full and one at 11, he has a charger on it now. I am beginning to suspect the starter has issues.

 

[rsn48]

I think part of boating is killing one set of batteries before you figure it all out. Don't ask me how I know.

 

[Comodave]

Mine are tough to check and fill. I bought a battery jug water filler bottle with auto shutoff from Amazon for $13. It works great, holds 1/2 gallon of water. You stick it in and press down. Water flows into battery and shuts off when the battery is full. You don’t have to even look into the hole.

 

[Knotyourwife]

Mine are tough to check and fill. I bought a battery jug water filler bottle with auto shutoff from Amazon for $13. It works great, holds 1/2 gallon of water. You stick it in and press down. Water flows into battery and shuts off when the battery is full. You don’t have to even look into the hole.

Seller had one of those down by the batteries, excellent gadget!

 

[Comodave]

Yes, with it I can fill them, without it I have to pull 2 of the batteries to get to the back ones. Well worth $13.

 

[High Wire]

You do know that the "water" in the batteries is not water, its very strong acid that will severely burn or blind you, right? The "water" is only what is added to an existing battery.

 

[ghost]

Only one of the four batteries appeared to be low on water, that was a two hour project, but I topped them all off. One of the boaters here just checked with a voltage meter and 3 were full and one at 11, he has a charger on it now. I am beginning to suspect the starter has issues.

I don’t think you can blame the starter just yet. Yes, I’ve been there too. Embarassing, I know about watering batteries.

Fill them up, below the top of the case and above the lead plates. Distilled is best, if you have it or expect the batts to survive. Charge them well. Come back tomorrow. Disconnect them. Let them rest. Get one of the cheap turkey baster style battery testers. Test every cell in every batt and record the results.

At that stage, you can make decisions on whether to replace them all, or some of them. One bad cell can ruin the others.

I survived doing this once by replacing a cell. The next time I was not so lucky and replaced them all.

Yeah, it’s a bit of a right of passage unfortunately. Motivation to monitor constantly and water on a schedule.

I now use a float hub to send alerts when voltages are not normal. A notebook with a pencil can be nearly as reliable if you will use it. I won’t. I can say that now. Thought I could. I was wrong!

 

[firehoser75]

First off, even though the battery(s) in question could be "shot", you might as well top them up (with distilled water) and try to "save them" by fully recharging. However, if one battery in a bank of batteries does turn out to be shot (not take and hold a charge), you really should replace the entire bank (for best results including best use of your dollars)! All batteries in a bank should be of the same age and type, and ideally even the same manufacturer and capacity. In that way, coupled with proper charging and maintenance, you will obtain the optimum performance and life out of your bank.

 

[Comodave]

First off, even though the battery(s) in question could be "shot", you might as well top them up (with distilled water) and try to "save them" by fully recharging. However, if one battery in a bank of batteries does turn out to be shot (not take and hold a charge), you really should replace the entire bank (for best results including best use of your dollars)! All batteries in a bank should be of the same age and type, and ideally even the same manufacturer and capacity. In that way, coupled with proper charging and maintenance, you will obtain the optimum performance and life out of your bank.

+1. Agree.

 

[PM]

I see you are in Florida, winter should not be a problem there. If you have a battery very low on fluid and the battery does not have much of a charge in it, it is very likely that in Northern Climes the battery will burst, or at least crack.

If this happens to you be very cautious of removing the batteries from the boat. Hopefully they will be in boxes but if not there is every possibility that you now have battery acid in your bilge. Even if they are in boxes everything that drips off the batteries is highly corrosive to your cloths, eyes, shoes and floors.

At any rate, at any location, proceed with caution !

pete

 

[BruceK]

That 3 are full and one is at 11v, and you could not start the engine, suggests the 11v one is the "start" battery. You need to investigate that but if so, the other 3 could be "house" and you may get away with replacing the "start" one if as I expect, it doesn`t come back. There are multi stage chargers which claim to diagnose and if possible, revive sick batteries.I hope that is what your neighbour is using.

 

[Knotyourwife]

All 4 batteries just test at 12v, I learned how to use a voltage meter..But the display at the helm still showing its low and still only click click click when I turn it over...A neighbor said maybe a silinoid is bad. Any thoughts? I did whack it a few times like I used to have to on a my old truck. No dice.
'

 

[BruceK]

If your reading really is just 12v and not for example, 12.8 your batteries really are low, about 25% charged, as the helm display shows. 12.6v or above,read when the batteries are not on charge and have not just used, indicates full.
The 5 hours between your last 2 posts is not enough time to recharge them. I don`t know the capacity of the charger, or if it is trying to charge all 4 at once, or how the charge is divided between banks, if they are separate. But before condemning the batteries, give them a good long charge, 24hrs would be good.


As your batteries have opening caps you can remove them to see if the cells are bubbling under charge. Remember the liquid in the batts is sulfuric acid, not water, so be careful doing this, it doesn`t agree with clothing, skin, eyes, etc. If you see that only 2 of 4 cells of a battery are charging, the other 2 are likely dead and so is the battery. You may need to top up during charging, liquid needs to cover the plates or be up to any indicators, forming a meniscus or "fish eye" look.
The hydrometer test readily available and cheap at boat or auto parts shops) is a better test than voltage, but again, only worth doing after the batts are as charged as they can be. An info "how to" sheet should come with the hydrometer.
I suggest resolving battery condition before blaming other items. I don`t think you are there yet. There are way smarter elec guys here who I hope will help.

 

[Knotyourwife]

That's good to know-and I am not sure how they collectively charge or if I need to charge each one individually. Lets start by what should a battery read at full charge?

 

[BruceK]

That's good to know-and I am not sure how they collectively charge or if I need to charge each one individually. Lets start by what should a battery read at full charge?

As above, 12.6v or above is said to indicate "full". Voltage test is an indication, but won`t tell you how the battery holds charge or bounces back after doing some work, ie coping with a load. But, it`s a good start. You`d need someone to inspect your charger to tell how it is set up. Can you tell us the brand, any amp rating shown on it, maybe it says the number of charge channels, assuming it is a modern type. Posting a photo of it might help the experts.

 

[Island fish lifter]

You cannot judge a battery by just reading the sitting voltage. The batteries condition depends upon the ability to supply an adequate amount of amperage while maintaining a certain amount of voltage over a period of time.
Normally a battery has a CCA recommendation which can be measured by a load test. If your battery fails this test it will need to be replaced. More times that not, simply topping off the water will not revive them as they are already sulphated.

 

[sunchaser]

Knot
Suggest you go to two websites, Trojan's and Victron's. Spend an hour or two reading each one and dozens of associated links. You'll come away a lot more informed than most of us.

 

[Lollygag1]

I found out about the battery water issue last year when I woke up and the boat did not start. Added water and they would hold a charge for a short time but were shot. Turned out they were 8years old so likely at end of life. Bottom line I bought a new bank and now have them on my engine room check list.

Actually have 3 checklists so I do not forget anything.
pre-cruise
Monthly
Seasonal

 

[firehoser75]

Checklist are a great idea! Now if I can just remember where I put them, and also remember to look at them

 

[jimisbell]

Mine are tough to check and fill. I bought a battery jug water filler bottle with auto shutoff from Amazon for $13. It works great, holds 1/2 gallon of water. You stick it in and press down. Water flows into battery and shuts off when the battery is full. You don’t have to even look into the hole.

Wow, that is OLD SCHOOL. That type of jug was available in the Model A Ford days. I am surprised they still make them. I have an old one with the FORD logo on it....LOL

 

[MYTraveler]

All 4 batteries just test at 12v, I learned how to use a voltage meter..But the display at the helm still showing its low and still only click click click when I turn it over...A neighbor said maybe a silinoid is bad. Any thoughts? I did whack it a few times like I used to have to on a my old truck. No dice.
'

12 volt batteries consist of 6 cells, each nominally 2 volts. When fully charged, a good 12 volt battery will actually have about 13 volts. If one of the cells is shorted, the battery's remaining cells will provide a voltage of about 11 volts. It sounds to me like your 11 volt battery has a shorted cell, especially if it will not charge to a higher voltage. Not much you can do about that. But, even the batteries that read 12 volts could be shot, as it is not the voltage potential that is destroyed, but instead the batteries' capacity. As long as there is a little capacity left (and there always is at least a little, unless the cell is shorted), you can charge the battery up and get it to read normally. But, any load at all, particularly the load of a starter motor, will quickly use that little remaining capacity and fully discharges the battery. (That is batteries are tested with a load test, not just a voltage test.) The good news is that capacity can often be at least partially restored through a process known as "equalization". That takes a special battery charger, but may be worth a try.

 

[Xlantic]

All 4 batteries just test at 12v, I learned how to use a voltage meter..But the display at the helm still showing its low and still only click click click when I turn it over...A neighbor said maybe a silinoid is bad. Any thoughts? I did whack it a few times like I used to have to on a my old truck. No dice.
'

If you get the "click click click" I would think the problem is low power from the battery rather than an issue with the solenoid.

Besides issues with the battery itself, you should check that all cable connections are clean and tight.

 

[MurrayM]

Wow, that is OLD SCHOOL. That type of jug was available in the Model A Ford days. I am surprised they still make them. I have an old one with the FORD logo on it....LOL

That’s what we have as well. Four 6 volt golf cart batteries in series parallel five years old and still going strong.

Plews watering can I believe it’s called, if my memory is any good...

 

[BobMc]

Before you go out and buy all new batteries, I suggest you top off the batteries with distilled water (as others have indicated you need to do - check them before you start the engines) and then connect them to a BatteryMinder to see if it will bring the batteries back to life. Probably need to do one battery at a time.

I keep one to use from time to time on my group 31 starting battery.

You can find them here: Batteryminders.com